“Let It Go!”: What Brands Should Do To Promote Resale Behaviour

Problem of practice

While recent years have seen rising consumer interest and demand for second-hand goods, one persistent challenge remains: the supply. Consumers are often reluctant to part with their possessions, even those that they no longer use. This reluctance is especially strong among those who purchase new products firsthand, as they tend to form deeper emotional connections with such products, which inhibits their re-entry into the supply cycle. So how can brands break this deadlock? The answer lies in recent research by Feifei Huang and Vincent Chi Wong, which suggests a virtuous ‘reuse-resale cycle’ — second-hand purchases involve weaker attachment, which reduces barriers to reselling.1 Thus, this increases supply and encourages more consumers to buy second-hand products. To leverage this insight and provide brands and marketers with a playbook of interventions, we outline a framework to identify the most effective nudges based on purchase type and consumer type. These strategies can help expand the second-hand market and align with sustainability goals

Issue 1

Fatima had bought a new jacket a couple of years back. At the same time, Seema had also bought a similar jacket second hand. Two years passed since the purchase, and neither of them wears their jacket so often now. So, if they were to resell the jacket, who would be more likely: Fatima or Seema? Recent research by Huang and Wong suggests Seema would be more likely to resell hers. According to their research, consumers are more willing to resell a product they purchased second hand, as most consumers form weaker connections or emotional attachments to second-hand products. When consumers buy a product first hand, they develop unique personal associations with it, create a strong connection and link it to their identity. However, if it is a second-hand purchase, they recognise its ‘history’ with a previous owner, weakening their personal association, making them more willing to resell it.

The second-hand market (recommerce) is expected to grow rapidly in the next few years. The second-hand market for apparel is projected to cross USD 360 billion by 2030, at a growth rate upwards of 10%.2 Products related to entertainment (movies, music, games and books) are the second popular category in the secondhand market in China and France .3,4 Responsible brands are increasingly looking at facilitating used products transactions, be it directly from the brand to consumer, from retailer to consumers or from consumer to consumer.5 A 2025 resale report by ThredUp points to increasing global demand for second-hand goods, highlighting that 76% of US-based retailers are exploring resale options. 6

Barriers to supply

While the push so far has been on building demand for second-hand products, encouraging resale behaviour to expand the supply side is equally important. There are three key barriers to the supply side:

Ÿ The consumer barrier: This can be described as the consumers’ materialistic attachments and low motivation to part with products that are still usable, which adversely affects sustainability and sharing economy goals. Unwillingness to part with a product could stem from product attributes or consumer emotions. For instance, 85% of women keep clothes that do not fit, hoping to re-wear them or out of guilt about discarding them.7 This limits the inflow of products available in the second-hand market.

Ÿ The market barrier: The resale market receives sporadic supply of low-quality and limited variety of

Marketer’s playbook

The research by Huang and Wong suggests that people have a strong tendency to retain products that they have bought, even when they are no longer useful. But when consumers buy second-hand, they are more likely to resell, which in turn makes more products available in the second-hand market for others to buy, creating a virtuous ‘reuse and resale cycle’ (see Figure 1).

Figure 1: The virtuous reuse-resale cycle

product is weaker

Source: Created by the authors based on research by Feifei Huang and Vincent Chi Wong. “From Second-Hand to Third-Hand: Reuse and Resale Cycle.” Journal of Consumer Research 51, no. 1 (2024): 104–13. https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucad042.

Brands can leverage this insight to encourage consumers’ participation in the resale cycle through a two-pronged approach:

1. Promote more second-hand buying behaviour by enhancing accessibility to second-hand markets and products. Promoting second-hand transactions can reduce waste, strengthen supply in resale markets, and drive sustainable consumption. Some ways to encourage resale behaviour are:

People have a strong tendency to retain products that they have bought, even when they are no longer useful. But when consumers buy second-hand, they are more likely to resell, which in turn makes more products available in the second-hand market for others to buy, creating a ‘reuse and resale cycle’

Ÿ Encouraging sale and purchase of second-hand products between consumers by providing visibility and easy matching. Some examples are C2C platforms such as OLX and eBay.10 In the not-forprofit space, thrift stores such as Goodwill attempt to encourage repurchase and resale behaviour.11

Ÿ Facilitating return of used products to the retailer/brand for resale, like Patagonia’s worn wear programme, where clothes returned by consumers are refurbished and resold, IKEA’s Buy Back Friday, where IKEA buys back customers’ furniture at double price and H&M’s initiative to provide store credit in exchange for any used clothes.12,13,14

Ÿ Strengthening government/regulatory mechanisms

to support and reward such circular efforts, such as India’s Consumer Protection (Direct Selling) Rules, 2021, an act that establishes guidelines to protect consumers.15

2. Incentivise those who have bought first hand to resell. If marketers can find ways to weaken consumers’ connection with new products, it could encourage resale behaviour, enhancing product reuse, thereby limiting new production. Some ways to incentivise reselling are:

Ÿ Promoting decluttering techniques and popularising practices such as the KonMari method can encourage minimalism and help people break attachment with their possessions.16 Reframing the practice of reselling as a form of decluttering and doing good may enable individuals to feel the ‘warm glow’ effect and encourage weaker attachment with their possessions.

Ÿ Including prompts on mindful consumption and highlighting the adverse impact of materialism on consumer well-being in brand messaging and social awareness campaigns can sever or weaken product connections. For example, Back Market, a marketplace for refurbished tech, highlights the absurdity of the obsession for possessing the ‘newest’ gadgets.17

Management Practice Insights Vol 4

Issue 1

Ÿ Establishing a personal connection with the prospective buyers of products that may have strong nostalgia or meaningful associations. This connection may enable meaningful transfer to some extent, thereby increasing willingness to part with the product. For example, a ‘mother’ sharing memories of a LEGO set for sale on a P2P platform might create a sense of ‘entrusting to’ the future owner, which could weaken ties.

Ÿ Offering return and exchange programmes and specifying the time period for exchange at the time of the original purchase could create an association of temporary ownership, thus weakening the consumer-product connect and making the consumer more inclined to return the product. The brand can then resell returned products. Aretto, a flexible-size shoe brand for children, asks consumers to return the shoe when the child outgrows it and take a bigger size in exchange.18

Ÿ Promoting rental models like Rent the Runway and Flyrobe may also help shift consumer mindsets from ownership to ‘temporary custodian’, strengthening the circular view of consumption.19

Pitfalls to manage

Ÿ Marketers face a conundrum with resale programmes: On the one hand, they want to encourage consumers to return products. But they also want to generate more sales and create brand associations of long-lasting products, rather than evoking ‘resale’ as the dominant association. For instance, a durable brand could risk signalling lower quality if it encourages consumers to replace the product sooner or if secondhand sales see a surge. Lower prices can impact demand and price perception of new products sold by authorised dealers.

Action: Brands can introduce well-timed nudges after a defined period post-purchase, based on the typical product lifespan. At that point, promotion of reselling can happen without harming brand associations or losing customer loyalty. Another way could be to reframe ‘resale’ behaviour by focusing on the brand portfolio.20 A customer may be persuaded to resell one product, while their attachment to the brand can be strengthened by trading within the brand portfolio.

Ÿ Apart from this ‘qualitative cost’, managers also need to consider the operational and financial costs of introducing a resale programme.

Action: Brands can incorporate technology-enabled resale processes with integrated quality-control mechanisms in their existing loyalty

21

programmes.

Management Practice Insights Vol 4

Issue 1 Jan-Jun 2026

Action: Brands can monitor the percentage of products included in resale programmes, the typical product lifespan, and customer participation rates across segments.22

Product and consumer type

How brands can create successful resale programs also depends on the type of product and consumer:

Product type: While second-hand purchases are likely to form weaker connections, this may not always be true. Consumers can create a strong connection with second-hand products if previous ownership reinforces desired associations, such as with luxury or aspirational brands such as when buying a second-hand Harley-Davidson from someone who embodies the brand.

Products bought first-hand also may not always forge strong connections. A consumer’s connections may be stronger for brands like Patagonia that align with their self-expression and emotional benefits.23 Such connections may not appear to be as strong for products purchased for their functionality, like a vacuum cleaner, which gets the job done but rarely carries any emotional weight.

expected to grow rapidly in the next few years. The second-hand market for apparel is projected to cross USD 360 million by 2030, at a growth rate of more than 10%

Consumer type: How resale tendencies play out also depends on the type of consumer the brands need to target. Take the instance of a writer who opened up about her hoarding tendencies for high-end garments.24 Even without looking at such extreme cases, consumers can be classified along the continuum of minimalist or maximalist tendencies. Some are frugal and detached, while others are unable to part with their possessions, as their sense of self is tied to the products.

Marketers can apply different nudges for each type of consumer orientation and nature of connection (see Figure 2): emotion-laden narratives, status or identity-driven rewards, or ease/convenience.

The final pitch

Brands’ encouragement of resale behaviour can bring more products back into the supply chain and help the ‘reuse-resale’ cycle to flourish. A report shows that

Consumer orientation

Minimalistic Materialistic

Nature of connection

Source: Created by the authors (axis variables are drawn from the research by Feifei Huang and Vincent Chi Wong. “From Second-Hand to Third-Hand: Reuse and Resale Cycle.” Journal of Consumer Research 51, no. 1 (2024): 104–13. https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucad042)

Sukriti Sekhri Gupta is Assistant Professor in Ruppal Walia Sharma is Professor in the Marketing department at SPJIMR. the Marketing department at SPJIMR. You can She is also chairperson of Post Graduate Programme in General reach out to her at sukriti.sekhri@spjimr.org Management and Head of Delhi Centre. You can reach out to her at

ruppal.sharma@spjimr.org

This article may contain links to third-party content, which we do not warrant, endorse, or assume liability for. The authors’ views are personal

REFERENCES

Feifei Huang and Vincent Chi Wong, ‘From Second-Hand to Third-Hand: Reuse and Resale Cycle’, Journal of Consumer Research 51, no. 1 (2024): 104–13, https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucad042.

2 Fanny Moizant, Felix Krueger, Catharina Martinez-Pardo, Pierre Dupreelle, Judith Vitrani, Charles Gardet, Dounia Wone, Alice Hebrard-Lemaire, Delphine Baz, Erika Dietze, and Maria Lasa Aresti, ‘Resale’s Next Chapter: How Fashion and Luxury Brands Can Win in the Secondhand Market’, BCG Global, 1 October 2025, https://www.bcg.com/publications/2025/how-fashion-luxurybrands-can-win-secondhand-market.

3 Umair Bashir, ‘Most Common Second-Hand Purchases by Category in China 2025’, Statista, 25 November 2025, https://www.statista.com/forecasts/1348226/most-commonsecond-hand-purchases-by-category-in-china/.

4 Umair Bashir, ‘Most Common Second-Hand Purchases by Category in France 2025’, Statista, 25 November 2025, https://www.statista.com/forecasts/998302/most-commonsecond-hand-purchases-by-category-in-france/.

5 Chen Pang et al., ‘Leveraging Strategic Consumer Behavior in Consumer-to-Consumer Resale: From Economic and Environmental Perspectives’, Omega 120 (October 2023): 102924, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.omega.2023.102924.

6 Thredup, ‘2025 Resale Market and Consumer Trend Report’, ThredUp, March 2025, https://www.thredup.com/resale.

7 Danica Lo, 85% of Women Keep Clothes Even If They Don’t Fit: I Do This! Do You?, Glamour, 6 August 2013, https://www.glamour.com/story/85-of-women-keep-clotheseven.

8 Emma Ruminski, Poor Quality Donations ‘Costing South West Charities Money’, BBC, 4 February 2025, https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cnvqep9rn0yo.

9 Nor Ashikin Ab Manan et al., ‘Factors Influencing Purchase Intention of Second-Hand Clothing Among University Students’,

International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science

IX, no. II (2025): 558–68, https://doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.9020045.

10 OLX INDIA, ABOUT OLX INDIA – OLX India Careers, 2025, https://careers.olx.in/olx-background/.

11 Minda Zetlin, ‘After 123 Years, Goodwill Hit $5.5 Billion in Sales by Turning Retail Wisdom Upside Down’, Inc, 4 December 2025, https://www.inc.com/minda-zetlin/after-123-years-goodwillhit-5-5-billion-in-sales-by-turning-retail-wisdom-upsidedown/91272957.

12 Patagonia Help Center, What Is Worn Wear?, 15 November 2019 https://help.patagonia.com/s/article/What-is-Worn-Wear.

13 Corporate news, IKEA Second Hand Furniture Buy Back Program, Ikea, 3 September 2021, https://www.ikea.com/au/en/newsroom/corporate-